Best Cheesesteaks in the Outer Banks on Hatteras Island

  • Posted on

Discover the Best Cheesesteaks in the Outer Banks on Hatteras Island

Hatteras Island is a nice place near North Carolina. People love its great beaches and small towns. One special thing about Hatteras Island is the tasty cheesesteaks! If you want the perfect cheesesteak, you are in the right place. Cheesesteaks have yummy steak slices and melted, gooey cheese. We found the best places on the island for cheesesteaks. Are you ready to hear about them?

Angelo's Pizza

Angelo's Pizza is found right in the heart of Buxton, a place both residents and visitors appreciate. They're famous for their pizzas, but their cheesesteak also really shines. This special sandwich has thinly sliced steak, sautéed onions, and the right blend of cheese. All these ingredients are tucked into a fresh hoagie roll. The dedication Angelo's Pizza has to good taste and top-quality ensures each bite is enjoyable. The simplicity and perfection with which they make their cheesesteak sets it apart, and leaves a memorable mark on those who eat it.

Follow Russ' advice and grab one of these cheese steaks while your kids enjoy the arcade at Angelo's Pizza.  You won't regret it!


A short drive from the beach, BROS in Avon presents a distinct interpretation of the classic cheesesteak. Their version features expertly seasoned beef slices combined with a secret cheese blend that melts seamlessly into the meat, offering a creamy texture complementing the robust flavors. BROS takes pride in their artisanal approach, utilizing only the freshest local ingredients to breathe life into their culinary creations.

Nino's Pizza

Nino's Pizza cheesesteak is an iconic choice for sandwich lovers. Packed with juicy steak, melted provolone cheese, and flavorful green peppers and onions, this sandwich bursts with rich flavors. Nino's warm, welcoming vibe creates a perfect setting to savor the meal after exploring Hatteras Island.

Bros Sandwich Shack

Gidget's Pizza & Pasta

While famed for Italian fare, Gidget's Pizza & Pasta serves a remarkable cheesesteak. This gourmet sandwich showcases prime steak cuts, a mixture of mozzarella and American cheeses, and a tangy house-made sauce, adding a unique twist. The result is a sophisticated version of the classic Philly cheesesteak, available right here on Hatteras Island.


Hatteras Island, renowned for its tranquil scenery and ocean adventures, also caters to cheesesteak enthusiasts. These restaurants offer distinct cheesesteak variations, ensuring a suitable option for all preferences. From Angelo's Pizza's traditional flavors to Gidget's Pizza & Pasta's gourmet offerings, you're bound to find the island's best cheesesteak in a delightful and satisfying journey. When visiting Hatteras Island, be sure to stop by these spots for a taste of the finest Cheese steaks around.